[Asiacrypt2025] Your Proof in [978-981-95-5112-5, ASIACRYPT 2025, Part IV, LNCS 16248, paper approval (679527_1_En, Chapter 16)]
Manigandan K Kumar R
manigandank.kumarr at straive.com
Sat Dec 6 11:04:02 CST 2025
Dear Dr. Tanja Lange,
Thank you for providing your approval.
We will then proceed further with the book publication process.
Thank you for your help and support.
---
Best Regards,
*Manigandan K (Mr.)*
Production Supervisor - Books Production
www.springernature.com
Straive |7th Floor, Block-C | Hardy Tower | Ramanujan IT City | Rajiv
Gandhi Salai (OMR) |Taramani | Chennai |India-600 113.
M +91 9965087680
manigandank.kumarr at straive.com
---
[image: SPi Technologies India Pvt Ltd] is a service provider of *Springer*
Nature
On Sat, 6 Dec 2025 at 08:02, Tanja Lange <tanja at hyperelliptic.org> wrote:
> Dear Mr. Manigandan,
> Thank you for sending the updated pdf. We have checked the changes and are
> very
> happy to see that all of them have been done. Thank you for the uick
> handling.
> We're happy to approve this version.
>
> All the best
> Tanja
>
>
> On Fri, Dec 05, 2025 at 02:41:49PM +0530, Manigandan K Kumar R wrote:
> > Dear Dr. Tanja Lange,
> >
> > I hope this email finds you well.
> >
> > I would like to inform you that we have incorporated your amendments and
> > attached the revised PDF for your final review.
> >
> > Please check the PDF and provide your comments/approval at the earliest
> to move
> > forward with the publishing process.
> >
> > Also, the conference will start on December 08 and we must publish this
> > proceeding by the end of this week. So it would be very much helpful if
> you
> > could provide your response by today.
> >
> > Thank you for your help and kind understanding.
> >
> > ---
> >
> > Best Regards,
> >
> > Manigandan K (Mr.)
> >
> > Production Supervisor - Books Production
> >
> >
> > www.springernature.com
> >
> > Straive |7th Floor, Block-C | Hardy Tower | Ramanujan IT City | Rajiv
> Gandhi
> > Salai (OMR) |Taramani | Chennai |India-600 113.
> >
> > M +91 9965087680
> >
> > manigandank.kumarr at straive.com
> >
> > ---
> > SPi Technologies India Pvt Ltd is a service provider of Springer Nature
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > On Sat, 29 Nov 2025 at 07:20, Tanja Lange <tanja at hyperelliptic.org>
> wrote:
> >
> > Dear Mr Manigandan,
> > I just went to your page to do another check but the page tells me
> that the
> > manuscript has been "implicitly approved". My co-author, Daniel J.
> > Bernstein
> > says that he had uploaded comments, so it should certainly not be in
> an
> > _approved_ state. Furthermore, it now still is less than 72h after
> your
> > email
> > sending us the link. I would also like to point out that the emal was
> > malformed
> > (see below) and came 4 days after the announced time, (26 Nov
> instead of 22
> > Nov). These, and the timely comments from Bernstein, should be
> enough to
> > grant
> > an extension, but mot importantly, the errors need to be fixed. So,
> please
> > send
> > us an updated version.
> >
> > This email covers the same issues submitted through the form and adds
> > information, just in case your system really didn't register our
> > complaints.
> >
> > Author information:
> > My primary affiliation is Eindhoven University of Technology;
> Academia
> > Sinica
> > is only a secondary affiliation. Hence, we had correctly put {3,2}
> next to
> > my
> > name. This got changed to {2,3} in the paper and the metadata lists
> them in
> > the
> > worng order of priority.
> > The locations of displaying the email addresses got changed, also
> > indicating
> > falsely indicatig Academia Sinica as my main affiliation.
> > I'm attaching our version to show that it was correct.
> > If your system cannot handle a {3,2} then please change the order of
> the
> > institutions to
> > 1 UIC
> > 2 TUE
> > 3 AS
> > so that Bernstein ends up with {1,3}, I end up woth {2,3} and
> Pellegrini
> > with
> > {2}. Please algin Pellegrini's and my email address with TUE.
> >
> > The use of "et al." in the author line at the top of pages is
> unacceptable.
> > All
> > author names fit.
> > Put "Daniel J. Bernstein, Tanja Lange, and Alex Pellegrini" in the
> header
> > on
> > the left pages.
> >
> > Table 1 is a very important table for this paper and we had ensured
> that it
> > was
> > prominently visible on the top of a page. In your version it
> apppears in
> > the
> > iddle of the text, right after the meniton, as if we didn't
> understand how
> > to
> > use latex properly. I understand that forr displaying the paper on
> the
> > Springer
> > link webpage the concept of page does not exist, but for the printed
> > version
> > and the rendering in pdf it does, so please reinstate the prominent
> > posiiton
> > that it had.
> >
> > The same applies for Table 2.
> >
> > Your editors removed chronological information, and information of
> what
> > relevance we give to the papers we cite, by changing how tations
> appear in
> > the
> > text. E.g.
> > "see [10], [5], [11], and [6]" is in chronological order and in the
> order
> > in
> > which the interested reader should consume these papers. This got
> changed
> > to
> > "see [5, 10, 11], and [6]"
> > which is giving fale priority to [5]. This is just one example and I
> fear
> > that
> > this was some manual process an editor went through, but that means
> that
> > this
> > editor now has to go through the manual proecess to revert this.
> > I strongly hope that this is not part of your editing guidelines,
> but if it
> > is,
> > please remove it. Authors know the works they are citing and we
> certainly
> > are
> > able to put numbers in increasing orders if we wanted to, hence, you
> should
> > assume that there is meaning in the ordering and not change it.
> >
> > The same comment applies to "[42], [27], [20], and [19]".
> >
> > In Section 7.4, "in Sage" is improperly indented, it is the ending
> of the
> > sentence after the display of a code snippet.
> >
> > It is absolutely inacceptable to truncate the list of authors in the
> > bibliography. Author names in mathematical publications are
> conventionally
> > listed in alphabetical order, making it unethical to specifically
> broadcast
> > a
> > "lead" author's name.
> > This applies to publications {1], [2], and [3], which, as you can
> see, are
> > ordered alphabeticaly, but I can assure you that Bernstein and me
> did our
> > fair
> > share of work for [2] and should get that work acknowledged. Besides
> the
> > issue
> > of academic credit, the list of authors is also important to judge
> the
> > level of
> > independence of a publication. If we were to portrait [2] in a more
> > favorable
> > light than [1] or [3] the reader should be able to see that our
> judgement
> > might
> > be biased due to involvement in [2].
> > I hope this explains why this is a really important issue. If your
> database
> > has
> > lost the information on the authors this must be fixed at the root
> and for
> > all
> > papers that link to it, not just for those few where the authors
> take the
> > time
> > to drag themselves through comparing the bibliography entries.
> >
> > There is also an "et a;." in the list of editors of [10].
> >
> > Since you're editing the file again anyways, we would kindly ask to
> fix two
> > typos that we noticed in reviewing the proof.
> >
> > * Please also insert a semicolon at the end of 3(b) in Algorithm 4.
> >
> > * Please change "c_{ab}" to "C_{ab}" in [8]
> >
> > Looking forward to hearing back from you
> > Tanja
> > On Wed, Nov 26, 2025 at 08:05:24AM +0530,
> manigandank.kumarr at straive.com
> > wrote:
> > > <style type="text/css">
> > > ul{margin:0; padding:0;}
> > > </style>
> > > <p>Dear Corresponding author,</p>
> > > <p></p>
> > > <p>We are in the process of publishing the <b>ASIACRYPT 2025, Part
> IV,
> > LNCS 16248</b> proceedings. During the publication process the final
> page
> > numbers and running heads are inserted, as is the
> reference/copyright line
> > at the bottom of the first page of the paper. In addition, any
> formatting
> > or capitalization irregularities are corrected and adapted to
> Springer
> > requirements. This way we accommodate your contribution not only for
> the
> > printed version but also for the various full text XML based epub
> formats.
> > </p>
> > > <p></p>
> > > <p>References are also modified to make them compatible with
> CrossRef,
> > which will permit cross referencing within SpringerLink and
> eventually
> > between different publishers and their online databases.</p>
> > > <p></p>
> > > <p>To make sure that no errors have inadvertently been introduced,
> we
> > would ask you to kindly check the final PDF of your paper, paying
> > particular attention to the references section. This can be done
> using our
> > e-proofing system. Via the web interface, you can download and check
> your
> > paper. You may then either approve it, or write your comments in the
> box.
> > Send us your reply no later than <b>November 28,2025 23:59 GMT</b>.
> If you
> > have not responded by then, the paper is automatically considered to
> be
> > approved. </p>
> > > <p></p>
> > > <p>Please find below the link to your paper:</p>
> > > <p></p>
> > > <p>https://proofs.straive.com/lncseproofing/download.html?rfp=
> > bq3sH3e0112851x16</p>
> > > <p></p>
> > > <p>If your paper has more than one corresponding author, each one
> will
> > receive this email. Please collaborate with the other corresponding
> author
> > (s) And make sure that your common feedback is entered into the
> eproof
> > system by one of you on behalf of all the others. (Please note that
> > comments may be entered only once!) Please note that we will only
> correct
> > errors that have been introduced during the publication process. This
> > should not be seen as an opportunity to copyedit or modify your
> paper in
> > any way.</p>
> > > <p></p>
> > > <p>The proof PDF is actually the online PDF which will - besides
> the
> > Fulltext XML based HTML version - be published on Springer Link
> http://
> > link.springer.com. The resolution of the file for the printed book
> will be
> > higher (max. 600 dpi) and any colored figures will be printed in
> black and
> > white.</p>
> > > <p></p>
> > > <p><b>E-mail address:</b> Please note that we standardly publish
> > professional e-mail addresses, but not private ones. If you have a
> > different preference regarding publication of your email address,
> please
> > indicate this clearly on the proof.</p>
> > > <p>
> > >
> > > Best wishes,</br>
> > > <b>Manigandan K.</b></br>
> > > Project Manager - Books Production</p>
> > >
> > > <span style="color:#20253d"><b>Springer <span
> style="color:red">Nature</
> > b></br>
> > > <span style="color:black">
> > > Straive, 7th Floor, Block-C, Hardy Tower, Ramanujan IT City, Rajiv
> Gandhi
> > Salai (OMR), Taramani, Chennai-600 113, India</br>
> > > M +91 (0) 9965087680</br>
> > > manigandank.kumarr at straive.com</br>
> > > <a href="http://www.springernature.com">springernature.com
> </a></br><br>
> > > ---</br>
> > > Springer Nature advances discovery by publishing robust and
> insightful
> > research, supporting the development of new areas of knowledge and
> making
> > ideas and information accessible around the world. We provide the
> best
> > possible service to the whole research community.</br>
> > > ---</br>
> >
>
>
>
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www.iis.sinica.edu.tw/pipermail/asiacrypt2025/attachments/20251206/e3b95008/attachment-0001.htm>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image.png
Type: image/png
Size: 1971 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://www.iis.sinica.edu.tw/pipermail/asiacrypt2025/attachments/20251206/e3b95008/attachment-0001.png>
More information about the Asiacrypt2025
mailing list